Blog – INCREDIBLY BORING STORIES https://boringstorybook.com By Brian Kirby Sat, 21 Dec 2024 03:37:15 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.7.1 https://i0.wp.com/boringstorybook.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/cropped-gIRL-bOUNCING.png?fit=32%2C32&ssl=1 Blog – INCREDIBLY BORING STORIES https://boringstorybook.com 32 32 209740796 Carol & John’s Comic Book Shop Holiday Art Show https://boringstorybook.com/carol-johns-comic-book-shop-holiday-art-show/ Sun, 15 Dec 2024 05:11:57 +0000 https://boringstorybook.com/?p=2998

One of my favorite events each year is the Holiday Art Show at my local comic shop, Carol & John’s. I’ve been contributing to the show for a few years, and my kids are able to donate their art as well!

Since 2013, Carol & John’s has organized their Holiday Art Show to help provide food security assistance for those in need. Submissions for the show are open to anyone willing to create art, specifically an original comic book cover on blank books that the shop provides. Everyone is able to try to win one of the donated cover art pieces in a basket raffle system. A dollar gets you one raffle ticket towards the cover of your choice. All proceeds go to The Greater Cleveland Food Bank, the largest hunger relief organization in Northeast Ohio. Last year, proceeds from the art show funded 18,888 meals. The lifetime total is 159,496 meals donated due to proceeds from the art shows.

Earlier this month, a stolen car was intentionally rammed into the front offices of the Food Bank, so this effort to help them out is especially timely.

Each year the art has a fun theme that the shop announces a few weeks ahead of time. Past themes have revolved around the pandemic, holiday movies, Marvel vs. DC, the Spider-Verse, and “What If?” This year’s theme asks artists to create a tribute to a classic comic book cover. Artists donate covers rendered in a variety of mediums, from crayons and markers to funny photoshops and digital art. It’s always a crazy mashup of comics lore, the holidays, pop culture, and Cleveland in jokes.

The aspect of the event that stands out to me is the all ages, everyone is welcome angle. An entire school class has even participated for the past few years. It’s delightful to see the kids’ art, and if my own kids are any indication, the opportunity to have art displayed in a real art show is a confidence boost and inspiration for young artists. It isn’t a “school” show, it’s unique and expands their community. Plus, they help raise money for a good cause. I love getting to collaborate with my kids, as they come up with their cover concept and title, and we mock up the type and fun “cover” graphics like the comics code stamp and vintage price tag.

I think my favorite cover my kids have created so far is “What If… Iron Man was a Frog?

Carol & John’s puts in the work and turns neighboring retail space into a gallery for a few days, where everyone can enjoy the art and place their raffle tickets. Every donated cover is an obvious labor of love. There are extremely talented and experienced artists involved whose work hangs next to work from someone who might be participating in an art show for the first time. You can see students who have participated multiple times grow into their own year over year. Everyone brings a creative concept and all of the artwork earns money for charity.

The show runs from Wednesday the 18th through Saturday the 21st. If you are unable to visit the shop/gallery on Cleveland’s West Side, you can still view all the covers and call in with a credit card to buy raffle tickets. Each cover will have numbers assigned and the extremely sweet, helpful people at Carol & John’s will place tickets in any cover’s basket for you if you give them the number. Winners are going to be drawn live at their Holiday Party on the night of December 21st!

These are just a handful of past covers for the show:

]]>
2998
Krampusnacht Doodling https://boringstorybook.com/krampusnacht-doodling/ Thu, 05 Dec 2024 22:23:03 +0000 https://boringstorybook.com/?p=2955 I picked up the new Sharpie creative paint markers last April and thought they had a unique look when doodling on construction paper, and now I’m trying the idea out on a fun project about Krampus, the European folk monster who punishes naughty children at Christmastime. I’m loving the results so far!

]]>
2955
#kidlitartpostcard November 2024 https://boringstorybook.com/kidlitartpostcard-november-2024/ Mon, 11 Nov 2024 00:05:12 +0000 https://boringstorybook.com/?p=2618 On the first Thursday of each month, children’s book illustrators from around the world share illustrations across social media using the hashtag #KidLitArtPostcard.

Illustrator Gina Perry is kind enough to organize this event exclusively on Bluesky and Cara.

Find out more at Gina Perry’s website.

Check out my #kidlitartpostcards

Brian Kirby Author Illustrator

Check out all the great art being posted for #kidlitartpostcard day!

]]>
2618
#kidlitpostcard October 2024 https://boringstorybook.com/kidlitpostcard-october-2024/ Thu, 03 Oct 2024 14:32:27 +0000 https://boringstorybook.com/?p=2559 On the first Thursday of each month, children’s book illustrators from around the world share illustrations across social media using the hashtag #KidLitArtPostcard.

Illustrator Gina Perry is kind enough to organize this event exclusively on Bluesky and Cara.

Find out more at Gina Perry’s website.

Check out my #kidlitartpostcards

Check out all the great art being posted for #kidlitartpostcard day!

]]>
2559
THE PIGEON vs. … A BABY BUNNY? https://boringstorybook.com/the-pigeon-vs-a-baby-bunny/ Mon, 05 Aug 2024 02:23:34 +0000 https://boringstorybook.com/?p=2232
Cartoon of Mo Willems Pigeon vs a baby bunny

One of the big pushbacks I see from companies, thought leaders, and institutions when it comes to leaving X and trying a new social media platform is “there aren’t enough people” or “they can’t leave all those followers.” But, who’s truly listening when accounts post? A large number of followers doesn’t always equal engagement with real people. Let’s dig in.

I think comparing a kidlit superstar’s social media engagement on X and a humble Bluesky account with 1/52 the followers can prove a point.

Mo Willems is among the most famous and prolific author/illustrators today. The Pigeon series of books has sold more than six million copies! His account on X (formerly Twitter) has close to 100,000 followers, and his team still posts really fun content there regularly. But what sort of impact does he have when he posts to X? Bluesky is a newer and increasingly popular social media platform that is similar to the Twitter of a few years ago… Could it be possible that Mo Willems would get a better response if he joined Bluesky?

A baby bunny might have the answer.

I’ve been pretty outspoken about why individuals, companies and institutions should leave X and try Bluesky after I saw horrific, violent photos posted to a children’s book event’s hashtag. So, let’s see what happens when we pit a social media post result from one of the world’s most popular children’s book authors and his beloved multi-million selling character on X against a post by… me, an unagented author/illustrator, and a tiny friend who lives in my yard, on Bluesky.

The contenders:

The pigeon on X
Brian Kirby on Bluesky

THE FAVORITE on X!
World-famous Mo Willems’ official THE PIGEON account on X!
(Plus an assist from another organization you may have heard of…The New York Yankees!) X says The Pigeon has 93,600 followers! 52 times as many followers as his Bluesky opponent!

VS.

THE UNDERDOG on BLUESKY.
The slightly less famous Brian Kirby, an unagented author/illustrator on BlueSky, along with a baby bunny that he saw in his yard. Brian has 1,800 followers on Bluesky. 91,800 fewer followers than The Pigeon on X.

The Posts:

The Favorite’s Post on X:
The Pigeon partners with Yankee Stadium (which has 31.2K followers itself) to promote Mo Willems Family Day with a post on X. Sounds like a really fun time for up to 46,537 (Yankee Stadium’s capacity) ticket holders! A big event! A huge promotion! Hot dogs!

Post Stats:

  • 1 Reply
  • 5 Retweets
  • 37 Likes
  • 2.8K User Reach (2.99% of 93.6K Followers) – 1K users more than Brian’s follower count on Bluesky)
  • 43 Engagements

The Underdog’s Post on BlueSky:
Brian notices an adorable bunny that is living under his backyard steps outside Cleveland, Ohio. He hastily shares a picture on Bluesky. Baby bunny does not have a social media account like Yankee Stadium does, so he is not tagged in the post. The bunny will not be appearing at a stadium. No promotional payment was exchanged between Brian and the bunny.

Post Stats:

  • 7 Replies
  • 11 Reposts
  • 247 Likes
  • 265 User Engagements (14.72% of 1.8K followers)

  • Brian and his baby bunny pal had 222 more user engagements than the Pigeon/Yankees team.
  • Mo & The Pigeon’s number of engagements was just 0.045% of their number of his “followers.”
  • Brian and the bunny’s number of engagements was 14.72% of his number of followers.
  • Brian’s post had 6.16 times the engagement of The Pigeon’s, despite having just 1.92% the number of followers.
  • X reports that The Pigeon’s post reached 2.8K users (2.99% of 93.6K Followers). If true, 43 engagements out of 2,800 is just a 1.5% engagement rate.
  • The percentage increase from 0.045 to 14.72 is 32,611%.

At least 265 people on Bluesky heard what I said, whereas we only have proof of 43 users hearing Mo Willems.

There is only one possible explanation.
93,557 of The Pigeon’s 93,600 followers must be Red Sox fans!!!

Ok, maybe this isn’t the only possible explanation. Maybe the real explanation is that every user who followed The Pigeon over the 15 years since his Twitter account was created in June 2009 (2009 was the last time the Yankees won the World Series!) may not still be visiting, especially now that the platform has changed to X. Maybe a hefty percentage of his more recent follows are not from real accounts, and bots do not understand the amusement of The Pigeon getting to eat a ballpark hot dog. Maybe X users have all become bus drivers. Maybe a baby bunny just has a better Klout score than a best-selling-worldwide-phenomenon author…? Maybe Bluesky’s lack of content-throttling algorithms and user base of actual human beings favors baby bunnies. Maybe X is indeed an empty arena claiming the seats that were filled back during the Eras Tour are today’s current attendance, while Bluesky is a standing-room only ballroom packed with fans waiting for a show.

A 6-year old in 2009 would now be old enough to have an adult beverage at the game. Time moves on.

43 Million People had Blockbuster Video cards.

I no way do I mean this as an attack on Mo Willems and The Pigeon. His whole team is creating great content! My kids love it! ❤

I just hope The Pigeon and all of his publishing industry pals join me on Bluesky.

The remaining company he keeps on X doesn’t deserve him.

Bluesky social

See more about how sticking with X over Bluesky is failing the publishing industry.

]]>
2232
A List of …Lists (and Feeds & Starter Packs) https://boringstorybook.com/a-list-oflists-and-feeds/ Mon, 08 Jul 2024 17:23:58 +0000 https://boringstorybook.com/?p=1899

The algorithm-free aspect of Bluesky is refreshing, but setting up your account can be a little confusing, so I’ve put together a little explainer with some of the top lists/feeds to follow.

When you connect with accounts that share your interests, check their profile for their lists, feeds, and starter pack tabs.

  • Feeds – User-created timelines of posts populated by options drawn from Bluesky, which may include keywords, date ranges, types of posts, and who is posting. Typically focuses on a specific topic or hashtag, or even a user list combined with other criteria.
  • Starter Packs – Up to 150 collected accounts organized/curated by a user, ideally on a unifying theme, with up to 3 related feeds available as well (don’t neglect toggling over to the feeds tab in a starter pack). You can follow all of the accounts in a single click, or follow any of the accounts individually. A time-saving way to start following people and related feeds! Think of Starter Packs as a personal referral, not a feed/list. You can make your own and not worry if others have similar Starter Packs. As with their initial invite code onboarding, Bluesky leans into referrals from real humans.
  • Lists – Collections of accounts created by a user. Following/pinning a list will let you see all of the posts everyone on the list is sharing, in a chronological timeline. Includes replies, where you can see who people are talking to. Focuses on people grouped by similarities (i.e. kidlit agents), and not a single topic (i.e. the agent could be talking about the amazing key lime pie they just had).

Charlene Chua used the analogy that switching between various feeds & lists is like changing a TV channel. You can control the content you see, rather than having an algorithm choose it for you. Some feeds and lists may seem similar, but are slightly different—such as the SCBWI list and feeds I’ve included. Debbie Ridpath Ohi‘s SCBWI feed is pulled from her curated list of identified SCBWI members/staff/faculty, while my SCBWI feed pulls the keyword/hashtag from anyone using it. Both are useful depending on what you want to see!



A great place to start and see current conversations and active users! This is a comprehensive feed that scans for kidlit-related posts from many lists of users actively moderated by multiple members of the Bluesky kidlit community. Filters out replies, and uses various keywords and hashtags to keep on topic. Some of the lists below are tied into this huge feed. More info—and to check to see if you are already eligible to appear in the feed—can be found here.

Admins:  Debbie Ridpath OhiBrian KirbyCharlene Chua.


An expansive 1,600+ user list with any and all kidlit-related accounts, illustrators, authors, agents, art directors, publishers, librarians, boosters, bloggers, etc.—where you see what everyone on the list is posting chronologically, no matter what the topic. Like a big cocktail party with thousands of guests. If you have any kidlit interests and want to be part of the Mega Feed, ask to me be added to this list. If activity on BlueSky seems quiet, checking in on this list of unfiltered posts is good way to see current activity and connect with people.

Admin: Brian Kirby


Collects posts tagged #KidLitArt. Like following the hashtag. Mostly used by illustrators of children’s books & children’s illustration, and for the monthly #kidlitart chat on Thursdays. A fantastic way to check out the great art users are posting.

Admin: Charlene Chua


Follow this to see all posts from illustrators who have an interest in creating art for children’s and young adult books, and comics/graphic novels.

Admin: Charlene Chua


Posts from illustrators who work on published (or publishing soon) children’s books – boardbooks, picturebooks, chapterbooks, middle grade, young adult, comics, etc.

Admin: Charlene Chua


A starter pack to easily follow #KidLit/children’s illustrators who are actively posting on Bluesky. Includes Feeds for kidlit & #KidLitArt as well!

Admin: Charlene Chua


A list of agents and agencies who represent kidlit/YA creators. Don’t harass anyone by querying/pitching via Bluesky unless they have asked! A great, growing list to follow.

Admin:  Debbie Ridpath Ohi


A starter pack to easily follow agents and agencies who represent kidlit/YA creators. Just hit “follow all” Don’t harass anyone by querying/pitching via Bluesky unless they have asked!

Admin:  Debbie Ridpath Ohi


A more specific starter pack to quickly follow all of ABLA’s agents that are on Bluesky! They have a handy list of their agents as well. A great way to help people connect with the whole agency presence!

Admin:  ABLA


Collected list of SCBWI members, staff, and conference faculty. You can find more info about the Society Of Children’s Book Writers & Illustrators: www.scbwi.org.

Admin:  Debbie Ridpath Ohi


Searches only Debbie Ohi’s SCBWI list for #scbwi hashtags as well as others related to kidlit or YAlit.

Admin:  Debbie Ridpath Ohi


Searches for any posts that have SCBWI hashtags and keywords, from any user.

Admin: Brian Kirby


A starter pack to easily follow #KidLit / children’s authors who are posting on Bluesky. The 50-account limit woefully underrepresents the volume of authors on the platform, but the included feeds are a great way to encounter and follower more authors.

Admin: Brian Kirby


All posts from a collection of published and pre-published middle grade writers.

Admin: Jaymie Heilman


All posts from a collection of writers (published and pre-published) working on YA contemporary and/or YA romance/rom-coms.

.Admin: Jaymie Heilman


A feed showcasing kidlit & YA book recommendations with NO self-promo, drawn from a curated list of users who use 📚👍 emojis to post to the feed.

Admin:  Debbie Ridpath Ohi


A collection of KidLit & YA editors who work with traditional publishing houses. Please do NOT pitch or query directly via Bluesky unless they specifically ask.

Admin:  Debbie Ridpath Ohi


All posts from a collection of K-12 Educators & Librarians. Also check the #Edusky & #Skybrarian hashtags!

Admin:  Debbie Ridpath Ohi


All posts from a collection of creators (writers, artists, colorists, editors, etc) who’ve worked on published (or publishing soon) comic books, series, and graphic novels aimed at MG and YA audiences.

Admin: Diana Sousa


A Starter Pack of folks who moderate & frequent #kidlitchat Tuesdays at 9pm eastern.
Follow the hashtag to join the chat!

Admin: Brian Kirby


Follows the #kidlitartpostcard hashtag to chronologically show posts to Gina Perry‘s wonderful monthly event (typically the 1st Thursday of the month, except for holiday delays) where illustrators post their art and information.

Admin: Kellie Nicely


Also – make your own lists, feeds and starter packs! The best part of Bluesky is having control over what your own timeline looks like. Take advantage. Debbie Ridpath Ohi has a wealth of information on her website, and all of the admins I’ve shown above have more lists, feeds and starter packs than the ones I’ve listed, all easily found on their Bluesky profile.

Find the ones that work for you, or make your own!


Also of interest:

The DISCOVER feed is administrated by Bluesky, and shows trending content from your personal network. You can click the ellipsis button at the bottom right of each post in the feed where it gives you the option to show more posts like that one, or less. It is like a curated social media algorithm, but you have more control.
Admin: @bsky.app



If you know anyone still on X that is wary of transitioning to Bluesky, share these tools to help them migrate! And show them why they should.

]]>
1899
Break up with your X. https://boringstorybook.com/break-up-with-your-x/ Sat, 06 Jul 2024 20:05:02 +0000 https://boringstorybook.com/?p=1821

I’ve been in Marketing with a capital M for a couple of decades, and have worked on large-scale online campaigns for companies like Taco Bell, Wendy’s McDonalds, Cancer Treatment Centers of America, Dannon, Toyota, and many more. I have experience looking at engagement data for huge companies, and have seen good and poor decisions made across the board as far as online marketing goes. I’ve also experienced the positive effects of a large user reach on platforms like Twitter and Reddit, and have had my content go viral to the point where it is a top trending topic for days. I understand the pull of a promised number of followers, and the years of work and luck it takes to build that following. 30 year olds today were 12 years old when Twitter launched, it is hard to pivot to building another thing. But I’m imploring agencies & publishers that are not migrating away from X because of their follower count to reconsider. Because the follower count and actual follower reach are two different things.

One need only look at the actual engagement numbers. The accounts created on X still exist, but most account owners have stopped regularly using them.

The follower count on X is an accumulated number, not a current one. It’s like the ticker on a turnstile in an abandoned railway station, showing everyone who passed through over 18 years. That number doesn’t mean the station is packed.

During a recent #kidlit pitch event on X (formerly Twitter—I think it is past time to keep calling it that), an account posted horrific, gory photos to the hashtag. Seeing this sort of content in a children’s book event is something that would have caused a huge uproar at one time. But I haven’t seen any mention of the posts or photos anywhere. I have screen captures, I know they were there.

Why are the publishers/media companies/agents & agencies not distancing themselves from an online space where something like this happens? Accepting the unacceptable? The answer I usually get is that they can’t move away from their follower count.

Without naming names, let’s look at the engagement that major publishing industry accounts are truly getting from their followers on X. Below are reply, retweet, like and post reach numbers from a publishing, education, and media company that has built up 236,000 X followers. Their posts nowadays reach only about 0.2% of that—fewer than 1.5k on average, and they typically get less than 10 engagements per post.

This same publisher recently shared a site-wide 40% off sale to their 236,000 X followers, and this is the engagement they had for that announcement:

Five likes and one retweet, despite their hundreds of thousands of followers. When you look at the post engagements, the sole retweet does not actually exist.

If they opened the window of their corporate offices and shouted at people on the street, would they get a better return on their marketing…?

Another publisher has about 37,000 followers on X—here are some of their recent post engagements:

The two retweets are from the author and illustrator of the book being posted about. If you are on X and see a publisher post, click through to see what the reply is. You will often find “whoohoo” or heart emoji ❤ replies from the mentioned author or illustrator, without any another interaction from the supposed thousands of followers. No shame for any creators, some of my favorites are among these sole responses, and I would do the same. They SHOULD be responding in support of the posts that are made. But are these posts reaching people who are not already aware of the book? Imagine the Beatles posting about their new single and the only person the post reached was Ringo.

Here is another example—this literary agency has about 9,000 X followers. Posts they share (that aren’t RTs from other accounts) are getting <10 engagements, and reach less than 5% of their follower count.

Here is another fairly well-known literary agency on X, with about 6,200 followers. Even their best-performing posts reach <10% of their followers, and have fewer than 20 engagements.

Is this marketing that works? Is the return on time and effort worth loyalty to a platform where grisly photos are posted to #kidlit-related hashtags? How many of a publisher’s or agency’s followers on X are actual human beings, interested in and capable of buying books? How many followers look like this?

What do engagements even look like for these big X accounts anymore? How many “likes” are starting to come from accounts like these?

How many replies look like the troll gibberish under this post?

All of this garbage ad content pours into #kidlit community hashtags and pitch events:

Automated bots even hijack the picture book events on X to share twisted “AI” book pitches:

Imagine an agent or editor having to sift through this nonsense to find a worthwhile pitch. And again, the horrors of war hijacked the hashtag during the final #pbpitch and posted gruesome, nightmarish photographs of children alongside picture book pitches for children’s stories.

Look at the engagement yourself for kidlit accounts. Pay attention to the volume and interactions they get. If you click through to view the handful of replies and retweets on posts, you will find most are from the authors and illustrators of the books mentioned, employees/other divisions of the same company, a few friends or family, bots or trolls. Not users that you would want to PROMOTE to.

https://x.com/penguinkids
https://x.com/simonkids_U
https://x.com/MacmillanKidsUK
https://x.com/HarperCollinsCh
https://x.com/Scholastic
https://x.com/scbwi

Why Bluesky?

Social media fatigue has set in for many people, and chasing down what the next big thing will be is exhausting. But instead of chasing down the next big thing, expecting it to be automatic, why not join in and help build a new community that works the way social media used to, connecting people? That’s what Twitter was 10-12 years ago, users building a following and trying new things, like chat events and pitch parties. The platform didn’t create those, it merely enabled users to make them happen. If more corporate and agency accounts put the effort into building a following on Bluesky, where there are already thousands of kidlit creators and agents interacting and building a framework to succeed, the positive feeling of discovery through connecting online can return. And you can curate your own content there, without an algorithm deciding what you should see.

Regaining a following is not automatic there, but with the new feeds and lists (ex: Agents, Editors, Illustrators, Kidlit Community, Librarians) that users have created (that contain THOUSANDS of Kidlit-related users posting fantastic content), people WILL find you if you post even a little genuine content and use a #kidlit hashtag. Users have already primed the pump for you.

Case in point—@andreabrownlit.bsky.social recently embraced Bluesky (Jennifer Laughran has been amazing in spearheading this shift), and has just 1.4k followers there as of this post. But ABLA’s recent announcement of their 2nd Chance Inbox already has 139 engagements. That means 10% of their Bluesky followers engaged with their post. Their most recent non-retweet on X had 5 engagements, just 0.022% of their follower count.

Look through the 139 engagements on that Bluesky post—those are from REAL people, relevant to their interests. ABLA has even made a list of their agents on Bluesky, to make it easy for everyone to connect with them.

Mallory Grigg, Senior Art Director at MacKidsBooks, recently posted a call for illustrators on both X and Bluesky at the same time. She has 9,133 followers on X, and just 874 followers on Bluesky. Look at the engagement numbers for each platform.

On X:

Looking through her 46 replies on X, there are 25 responses, two of which are ads, before you get to the responses labelled as “Probable Spam.”

There are legitimate responses that are unexplainably in this spam category, and the rest of the replies are hidden with this warning:

On Bluesky, where she has only 9.5% of the follower count that she has on X, her engagement is actually higher:

The 36 responses to her post on Bluesky have no ads or spam, and there is nothing that could be labelled as offensive content, but there are illustrators sharing samples, attempts to be helpful by referring indigenous artists, and a recommendation for finding the illustrator she’s looking for on the Cartoonist of Color database.

Engagements on X total 3.5% of Mallory’s follower count, while the engagements on Bluesky were 43.2% of her follower count there. Bluesky delivered 378 total engagements, while X delivered 320. Consider what the support of a MacKidsBooks presence on Bluesky might have achieved.

I’ve worked in marketing long enough to know that decision makers often look for receipts rather than results. It’s easy to impress the boss with a big number, and X counts on that. But marketing teams, agents and editors need to convince the decision makers to INTERPRET the data, instead of looking at hollow follower numbers. I believe they will find that the right thing to do completely coincides with the SMART thing to do.

Several of us who have been recommending Bluesky have been receiving pushback that amounts to “The agents aren’t there,” “the publishers aren’t there,” “the schools and libraries aren’t there.”

Why not? Tell them to migrate over. They are posting on X, spending time, effort and marketing paychecks to reach a minimal amount of users who may or may not even exist, and getting the sort of response a flyer on a coffee shop bulletin board would get, if soulless robots drank coffee. If they get their teams to join Bluesky and actually interact with their community, the return would be better, the community would benefit, and their presence will draw more truly engaging followers to the platform.

Gina Perry has even moved her popular #kidlitartpostcard event exclusively to BlueSky and Cara, and it was a great success, with 192 artists posting their art on BlueSky for the 1st event there!

It’s not just Kidlit where these engagement numbers are happening—check this thread about climate science from Katherine Hayhoe, which even breaks down the percentage of negative engagement her post received on each platform:

Why Not …Threads?

Threads does indeed have a lot of users registered, having been easy to onboard for anyone already connected to Facebook and Instagram. But it presents the same issues, particularly for Kidlit creators, that Facebook and Instagram have. Artists don’t want their images used for as fodder for AI learning. The algorithm favors clickbait over conversation. Engagement is lower than on Bluesky, despite Thread’s claim of 175 million users. And the release of Threads in the European Union was postponed amid regulatory uncertainty about how the app will use personal data. Sounds delightful, right?


I informally asked Bluesky users why they were drawn to Bluesky over Threads, and was surprised there were fewer answers about the copyright/AI/privacy issues, and the overwhelming response was Thread’s negativity:

My personal observation is that the platform believes its users would rather see Nestle get in a flame war with Wendy’s or Weird Al Yankovic, and not show the users you really want to follow in a chronological timeline. It’s what a non-Twitter user thinks Twitter was all about.

What Can You Do?

What can you do to get your agency, publishers, SCBWI, school, library, colleagues, etc. to make the change? Share this information with them—refer them to the feeds, lists and starter packs that have been created to help with onboarding. Email decision makers, your agent, publisher, art directors. Recommend they check out Debbie Ohi and her tutorials, Charlene Chua’s illustrator Starter Packs, and my guides for kidlit and the Kidlit Mega Feed.

Tell them they are playing an empty arena on X when they could be playing Bluesky’s packed ballroom.

To make it easy for everyone…
I shared a list of ways to easily onboard and connect with #kidlit on Bluesky, it will hopefully make Bluesky less of a mystery—another tedious social media platform with a funny name—and more a DISCOVERY of where the creative community, industry and book consumers are thriving.

]]>
1821
THE KIDLIT MEGA FEED! https://boringstorybook.com/the-kidlit-mega-feed/ Mon, 17 Jun 2024 04:19:05 +0000 https://boringstorybook.com/?p=1752 Kidlit mega feed by Debbie Ohi

The amazing Debbie Ridpath Ohi and Charlene Chua teamed up with me to pool our resources, creating a way of connecting quickly and easily with the kidlit community on the BlueSky social media platform:

THE KIDLIT MEGA FEED

…pulls in kidlit content from moderated lists compiled by multiple members of the community!

 Find out more info and how to post to the feed here.

One easy way to join in is to get onto my KIDLIT COMMUNITY list. This is one of the moderated lists that the Mega Feed pulls from. I’ve been adding users to this list steadily over the past year, and it is very inclusive. Ask me to add you if you don’t see yourself in the feed: @boringstorybook.com

but check to see if you are already eligible to appear in the Mega Feed HERE first.

This feed should truly help anyone who is looking to connect with other people in kidlit, including creatives, publishers, agents, agencies, boosters, chat/event moderators, SCBWI groups, librarians, educators, art directors, picturebook, publishing news, YA, MG, GN, etc. etc.

Bluesky does not have an algorithm that chooses content to show users, it allows users to choose the content they want to see. Our project pools several vetted lists from multiple moderators into one comprehensive feed, and also scans for a variety of kidlit-related keywords and hashtags in the posts to keep on topic and filter out unrelated content (i.e. no “I have a toe infection,” “My cat smells,” “I just really got into crypto” type posts). There are also NO REPLIES in the Mega Feed, although you can click on the individual posts to see responses if you would like, or visit the moderators’ original lists, which I recommend following as well.

The Mega Feed is like an algorithm run by discerning humans, serving curated #kidlit content! It’s intended to be a gateway to connect and join conversations, especially useful for new users to onboard quickly. We hope it brings back the days of actual engagement between humans, and gives everyone an alternative to posting into a void.

Explaining Lists vs. Feeds

Everyone on Bluesky can create LISTS of users, i.e. my list of anyone w/ kidlit interests, or Charlene’s illustrator lists (which also connect into the Mega Feed). Following a list means following EVERYTHING that all of the people on that list share. You can even make your own list and submit it to be considered for inclusion to the Mega Kidlit Feed.

Feeds can be built with lists or a host of criteria, such as a keyword, hashtag, emoji—they can be tailored more specifically to a topic, or combination of lists and topics. Like Debbie Ohi’s book bans feed. A great way to build a feed is via BlueSkyFeedCreator.com—their developer has been very helpful in getting this project going. Try and build your own feed!
(More about Lists vs. Feeds.)

Our new MEGA FEED combines multiple moderated lists of users (from a growing number of contributors) into one comprehensive feed and ALSO curates further by using specific hashtags & keywords while filtering out replies! There is no single person controlling the content, we have many lists, with more added all the time. Pooling multiple kidlit list moderators that serve a variety of kidlit interests should result in feed that provides a much easier way to jump in and take part.

There are a lot of people helping the community there, Gina Perry has made BlueSky and Cara the #kidlitartpostcard platforms; Brian LaRossa of Scholastic is extremely engaging and has been gifting portfolio reviews and doing AMAs exclusive to BlueSky; Jennifer Laughran seems to be dragging all of Andrea Brown Literary Agency over on her back—the agency has left Instagram and is establishing itself on BlueSky; Charlene hosts the #kidlitart chat; Bonnie Adamson and Greg Pincus host #kidlitchat

One last thing – share the feed with any holdouts you know on other social platforms. And remember, this is a work-in-progress effort, and many people are volunteering their time to benefit as many in the community as possible. Please interact patiently and kindly, as there are sure to be hiccups along the way. And a word of advice – be yourself and try to connect with people on BlueSky, rather than just promoting. You will have more success in finding people to support you.

Debbie Ohi, Charlene Chua, Brian Kirby
Screen caps of our planning sessions by Debbie Ohi

More about Kidlit on BlueSky

About BlueSky Mute Lists

Debbie’s BlueSky Tips

]]>
1752
#pbparty Finalist https://boringstorybook.com/pbparty-finalist/ Fri, 22 Mar 2024 13:44:20 +0000 https://boringstorybook.com/?p=1535
PBParty finalist 2024
Snoopy Dance! PBParty finalist 2024!

I participated in Mindy Alyse Weiss’ #pbparty this year and was announced as a finalist!

I submitted my story FOR SHENANIGANS ONLY as an author/illustrator and was one of 25 entries chosen for the illustrator’s showcase.

The event itself has been a great experience, with or without the finalist result. I was paired with 6 other authors for a ranking group, where we all read through and critiqued 6 of each other’s manuscripts. I was also lucky enough to get a critique from past 3x finalist author/illustrator Ellen Seal. I loved the stories I was privileged to read, and the ranking process, and hope to see stories I critiqued get published soon.

The showcase goes live on March 25, I will be following up with a more in-depth recap of the experience once the dust settles!

]]>
1535
A Spooky Doodle https://boringstorybook.com/a-spooky-doodle/ Thu, 14 Mar 2024 14:59:03 +0000 https://boringstorybook.com/?p=1428
Detective girl meets friendly ghost
]]>
1428